Monday, September 8, 2008

TQ2: Professional development, instructional desing and educational research design

TQ2: You have completed Wenglinsky, and you have read the two executive summaries that suggest serious failures in a major national reading program and in the best math and reading software. In three-to-five paragraphs, use what you learned from Wenglinsky to interpret the findings of the two reports. Suggest one or more plausible reasons for the poor results presented in the reports.

Both of the readings for this week are suffering from poor results. In my opinion, the problem might be instructional design, research design and professional development for teachers.

One of the biggest aim of using educational technologies is to triggering some changes from didactic, teacher centered instruction toward constructivist, inquiry-based and student centered and collaborative instruction.. My personal observation from both of the reports, teachers were still using didactic style of teaching. I assume that the software that they have been using for the research are drill and practice software (there is no explanation about how teachers used software during their teaching). I do not think that drill and practice software would help student to concrete some abstract concepts especially in math.

Providing more sustained, high quality professional development and overall (technical and instructional) support for teachers to challenge themselves in instructional technology is another crucial issue in technology implementation. In my opinion, professional development has two aspects; technical professional development (how to use software, how to deal with minor difficulties such as logging in, locked up computers, not working headphones and so forth) .The other aspect of professional development is to train teachers how to integrate technology to their content area. In my opinion, instructional support for teachers has always been missed by educational technologists, stakeholders and researchers. For reading and math software study, teachers had professional development; however it was limited to teach teachers how to deal with basic tech problems. I believe that teachers did not have any instruction about how to tap the software into their instructional designs.

Educational research design might be another reason for poor results. I think that people need to reconceptualize the educational research. There is an ongoing debate about qualitative vs. quantitative. Even Wenglisky is like swaying his ideas between two different research designs. I have no idea how to make an educational research better and more reliable. In order to design more articulated educational research, we need to define conditions for effective use, create new measures of progress and indicators of effective usage (measuring all the students with the same ruler, or not), design new approaches to assessment and more sensitive evaluation tools (Culp, Honey, Mandinach, 2003).

References:
Culp, K. M., Honey, M., & Mandinach, E. (2003). A Retrospective on Twenty Years of Education Technology Policy. U.S. Department of Education, Office of Educational Teachnology.

Books I select for reading.
The Children's Machine: Rethinking School in the Age of Computers By Seymour Papert.
A Whole New Mind: Why Right-Brainers Will Rule the Future By Daniel Pink

2 comments:

Adriane's Blogger said...

I agree...technology needs to be incorporated in a constructivist stlye of teaching otherwise it will not be effective.

Miro Liwosz said...

From what I gathered, the professional development went well and the faculty felt they were prepared for students. But you might have something in here. Proper training does not guarantee the success of instruction.