TQ9: In 3-to-5 paragraphs, discuss how these laws, and the policies that are developed to enforce the laws, should-or-should-not comply with the principle of least restraint. You should take a personal position here, as though you were a judge presiding over a challenge to the way a school or library has implemented a restrictive technology policy. An important consideration is that the laws are seldom clear, and that schools are given a wide range of possible ways to comply.
Internet is providing more accurate, up-date information for learners and educators at schools and libraries. However, current legal legislations (CIPA, COPPA and the likes) are restricting or denying access to information on the Internet. The most important issue with these legislations is safety which is OK. However, when I think about the first amendment of the US, I am having a hard time.
My interpretation about laws in the US is that every law regulated by US law authorities should be grounded in first amendment. First amendment says “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” In my opinion blocking or filtering Internet at school is the same idea with censorship. I believe that CIPA should be challenged according to first amendment.
While revisiting CIPA, regulators should think of what are the responsibilities of librarians, teachers and parents. Education is not just about schools. Home is another component of child’s education. If a school blocks computers at school, but home computers are not filtered by software or by adult. Kids still have an access to inappropriate content at home.
The other question crossing my mind is that why CIPA has been tied up with E-rate. It sounds like threatening people leaving them hungry. I believe that this side of the CIPA is the worst.
The other issue is that why we are filtering or blocking something is already in the air. I think we have to consider it. As a democratic country, US should develop another act for content creators. Content creators should learn to take into account of minor audiences.
CIPA and the likes are absolutely beneficial for K12. I think they are violating freedom of speech.
Sunday, October 26, 2008
Thursday, October 23, 2008
TQ8:Professional developments, obstacles, solutions...
TQ8: Teachers are the core of a formal educational process, and technology use depends almost completely on the classroom teacher. Staff development (professional development or continuing education) is necessary for teachers to understand the potential educational value of technology. It is also necessary to show teacher how to use the technology. This is not an easy process for many reasons. In 3-to-5 paragraphs, discuss the main obstacles to effective development and the best ways to plan for a successful staff development program aimed at helping teachers teach and helping children learn (sorry about the long sentence). Include two or three informal references from your readings.
Time is the biggest issue for professional development. Maine Learning Technology Initiative (MLTI) planned a great professional development. However, Maine teachers couldn’t use laptops effectively. Although state arranged some professional development, teachers did not have time to think about, to play with, to try with this new technology. Designing technology-supported instructions requires time. To overcome time problem, curriculum content should be cut at least 25 percent as Singapore did (Dede and others, 2005). By doing so, Singapore administration allow teachers to experiment with technology and develop new ideas about implementation of technology.
The other obstacle is “ speaking about big goals and standards”. We have to adapt the philosophy of “ little by little”. In my opinion, all the professional development sessions are pouring a lot of information in very limited time. Instead of doing so, professional development instructors should have realistic, and reliable goals.
Usually, professional developments have the approach of “one size fit all” If I were developing professional developments; I would offer some options such as online, face-to-face, individually. I am sure it will increase workload of professional developers; however, it will increase effective use of technology. I think most of professional education sessions are state-. government-, district-mandated.
Since the school district are having a hard time to find money for their technology plan. While tech directors are planning, they usually forget the” professional development” component. According to Dede and others (2005), EETT grant requires spending 25% of the funds for professional development. Professional development should be priority of a technology plan not a requirement, not a mandated. As a result of required or mandated professional developments, teachers have “just in case” type of professional sessions.
Time is the biggest issue for professional development. Maine Learning Technology Initiative (MLTI) planned a great professional development. However, Maine teachers couldn’t use laptops effectively. Although state arranged some professional development, teachers did not have time to think about, to play with, to try with this new technology. Designing technology-supported instructions requires time. To overcome time problem, curriculum content should be cut at least 25 percent as Singapore did (Dede and others, 2005). By doing so, Singapore administration allow teachers to experiment with technology and develop new ideas about implementation of technology.
The other obstacle is “ speaking about big goals and standards”. We have to adapt the philosophy of “ little by little”. In my opinion, all the professional development sessions are pouring a lot of information in very limited time. Instead of doing so, professional development instructors should have realistic, and reliable goals.
Usually, professional developments have the approach of “one size fit all” If I were developing professional developments; I would offer some options such as online, face-to-face, individually. I am sure it will increase workload of professional developers; however, it will increase effective use of technology. I think most of professional education sessions are state-. government-, district-mandated.
Since the school district are having a hard time to find money for their technology plan. While tech directors are planning, they usually forget the” professional development” component. According to Dede and others (2005), EETT grant requires spending 25% of the funds for professional development. Professional development should be priority of a technology plan not a requirement, not a mandated. As a result of required or mandated professional developments, teachers have “just in case” type of professional sessions.
Sunday, October 5, 2008
TQ6: Reflections on the tech plans I have worked on recently
TQ#6: Since you are juggling several projects, this TQ will serve only as a reflection on your progress and thoughts. I've asked you to think about technology planning in several ways. In 2-to-3 paragraphs, reflect on what you are learning, thinking, and questioning as you dig more deeply into each project. You may focus on just one project or more than one.
I will reflect my thoughts in three sections: reflections on Peabody Elementary School technology plan, School A’s strategic plan, and MLTI (Maine Leaning Technology Initiative).
Peabody Elementary School Technology Plan: I was thrilled when I first read about the effects of eMints program in the elementary school. School has very concrete evidences to say that “yes, we adopt eMints and increase our academic achievement”. Beyond the perfect technology program, I think how t eMints dedicated itself to professional development. It is not enough to set up a computer lab in a school, we should teach how to use it. I believe that there are so many aspects to teach a teacher sufficient amount of information about the new technology. The professional development should include,
· Troubleshooting for minor problems.
· How to integrate this technology into subject matter.
· How to adopt the ideas coming from more experienced teachers’ about in this technology.
· How to manage the new classroom (new technology will require new classroom management skills)
I have no idea about how much of this information was supplemented to Peabody Elementary School teachers. However, I know that professional development sessions helped teachers to figure out the ways to integrate new technologies.
The other striking fact is that eMints investment is a very wise and conscious choice. I think that the crucial point with writing technology plan is to make certain decisions without getting excited about the new technology.
School A’s strategic plan: As I mentioned on my previous posts this plan was the hardest one for me to read and follow the ideas. I have realized that how important the organization of ideas. At this point, this strategic plan is not a well-written plan. The ideas might be very valuable in terms of professional development, investment for the technology: however, it was very hard to follow the plan.
While writing a plan, technology directors should develop sound understanding about technology. In school A’s plan, there is too much focus on professional development while support issue is missing. There is no mention about contracting with an external vendor or developing a support team.
During one of our classes. Dr G. talked about something like " we are writing technology plans for distiirct people." While i was reading thorough A's plan, i absolutely got this sense. Okey we wrote 2008 tech plan and we archived it.
Maine Learning Technology Initiative: In my opinion Maine is suffering from lack of statewide policies. MLTI has taken an account of professional development and supporting issues. However, they have problems with taking off the laptops. The most important consideration is the insurance policy. Some of the school districts purchased some extra insurance for the take-home laptops. According to 2004 data, just 60% of the districts allowed students to take the computers home. I think that school districts cannot take the risk of teaching students their own responsibilities.
I have read the “Digital Balancing Act” article. I would desperately suggest everybody to read. The article is about Buckfield High School where the MLTI is initiated by students. Students are craving for the technology and I believe that if we give them laptops to their homes, they will take care of them very well.
During first years of the implementation, some of teachers are not eligible to own a laptop for their instruction. It is hard for me to figure out the reasons for this policy. Laptops are provided for the teachers who teach 7th of 8th graders at least 50 percent of a full schedule. Think about arts, second language teachers,
However, existing technical infrastructure is another problem. I agree that Macs are much better than PCs. What if school network is just compatible with PCs? At this point, better choice is to look for another grant to alter the entire network or to increase the compatibility of the existing network.
References: Trottee, A., (2004). Ditital balancing act, Education Week,
I will reflect my thoughts in three sections: reflections on Peabody Elementary School technology plan, School A’s strategic plan, and MLTI (Maine Leaning Technology Initiative).
Peabody Elementary School Technology Plan: I was thrilled when I first read about the effects of eMints program in the elementary school. School has very concrete evidences to say that “yes, we adopt eMints and increase our academic achievement”. Beyond the perfect technology program, I think how t eMints dedicated itself to professional development. It is not enough to set up a computer lab in a school, we should teach how to use it. I believe that there are so many aspects to teach a teacher sufficient amount of information about the new technology. The professional development should include,
· Troubleshooting for minor problems.
· How to integrate this technology into subject matter.
· How to adopt the ideas coming from more experienced teachers’ about in this technology.
· How to manage the new classroom (new technology will require new classroom management skills)
I have no idea about how much of this information was supplemented to Peabody Elementary School teachers. However, I know that professional development sessions helped teachers to figure out the ways to integrate new technologies.
The other striking fact is that eMints investment is a very wise and conscious choice. I think that the crucial point with writing technology plan is to make certain decisions without getting excited about the new technology.
School A’s strategic plan: As I mentioned on my previous posts this plan was the hardest one for me to read and follow the ideas. I have realized that how important the organization of ideas. At this point, this strategic plan is not a well-written plan. The ideas might be very valuable in terms of professional development, investment for the technology: however, it was very hard to follow the plan.
While writing a plan, technology directors should develop sound understanding about technology. In school A’s plan, there is too much focus on professional development while support issue is missing. There is no mention about contracting with an external vendor or developing a support team.
During one of our classes. Dr G. talked about something like " we are writing technology plans for distiirct people." While i was reading thorough A's plan, i absolutely got this sense. Okey we wrote 2008 tech plan and we archived it.
Maine Learning Technology Initiative: In my opinion Maine is suffering from lack of statewide policies. MLTI has taken an account of professional development and supporting issues. However, they have problems with taking off the laptops. The most important consideration is the insurance policy. Some of the school districts purchased some extra insurance for the take-home laptops. According to 2004 data, just 60% of the districts allowed students to take the computers home. I think that school districts cannot take the risk of teaching students their own responsibilities.
I have read the “Digital Balancing Act” article. I would desperately suggest everybody to read. The article is about Buckfield High School where the MLTI is initiated by students. Students are craving for the technology and I believe that if we give them laptops to their homes, they will take care of them very well.
During first years of the implementation, some of teachers are not eligible to own a laptop for their instruction. It is hard for me to figure out the reasons for this policy. Laptops are provided for the teachers who teach 7th of 8th graders at least 50 percent of a full schedule. Think about arts, second language teachers,
However, existing technical infrastructure is another problem. I agree that Macs are much better than PCs. What if school network is just compatible with PCs? At this point, better choice is to look for another grant to alter the entire network or to increase the compatibility of the existing network.
References: Trottee, A., (2004). Ditital balancing act, Education Week,
Wednesday, October 1, 2008
My educational philosophy and technology
There are three points underlying my teaching philosophy. Briefly, these are more student oriented learning environment, more web-supported learning environment, well designed professional development.
Student oriented learning environment:
In my opinion, it is the crucial point for instructional design in order to achieve 21st century skills. I agree with Wenglisky`s approach at this point. Educators need to shift towards constructivist environments. Today’s young learners need more critical thinking, higher order thinking. For years, the entire educational world stocked to Bloom’s first 2 or 3 steps of learning (knowledge-comprehension-application-analysis-synthesis-evaluation). In my opinion we need to look for the ways to improve students’ learning outcomes.
On the other hand, we need to alter the way we assess students. It should not just be limited with written exams, quizzes and the like. We need to focus on students’ learning outcomes, produces. Additionally, I am also aware of the fact that it is always more difficult to assess students according to their products. Teachers need more time, effort and thinking in order to assess students’ projects, products. Written exams, tests are always more attractive for teachers because all of the teachers have a mandated curriculum and state standards in hand.
Web supported learning environment:
First, I believe that Web will change the ways in which student learn, how they are willing to learn, how students are responsible for their own learning as it happens in Maine Laptop Initiative. Since I have been working on technology initiative of the state of Maine, I have realized that how an effective tool is the laptop.
The most important benefit of the web supported instruction design is more accurate and up-to-date information. When I think about my high school years, teacher and textbooks are the only source of information for me. My high school had good size library; however, school didn’t have a smiley librarian. To be honest, I had never visited the library in my high school years; therefore, my college student sister always searched for the information I needed in her university library. If we had Internet connected computers at school, I wouldn’t have to deal with any difficulty of reaching to information. Textbooks and teachers are the only source: therefore, in a non web supported environment, students don’t have a chance to communicate knowledge to many different perspectives. One of the biggest requirements of 21st century is being global citizenship. In my opinion, students will gain this characteristic only in a web supported environment.
Universities and K12 teachers always should go hand in hand. And one of the easiest ways to build learning communities is Web. For instance, Eric Langhorst, history teacher who created StudyCasts for his students to make them study on their test by listening Study Casts. As a result of StudyCasts, parents became more interested in their child’s learning, experts and authors involve to the classroom discussions (because Langhorst was using also blog to post the podcasts and to start a classroom discussion). Consequently, students were more engaged.
Well designed professional development:
While I was reading “Scaling up Success”, I was impressed how technology coordinators in other countries proposed the fact of time issue for teachers. Having a new technology, of course, will cause to spend more time. It is wise to cut at least 25percent of the curricula. By doing so, teacher spend more time thinking about how to integrate the new technology onto their content area. In Maine technology imitative, teachers have enough amount of train: however, they suffered from lack of time to design a web supported instruction.
Additionally, teachers should have professional development sessions which reflect the real life. Teachers should be involved in learning activities that are similar to their classroom activities.
References:
Wenglisky, Using technology wisely,
Chris DEDE and others, Scaling up success
Naime Kelekci, Best podcast practices
The Maine Learning Technology Initiative: Teacher, Student and School Perspectives Midyear evaluation report.
Student oriented learning environment:
In my opinion, it is the crucial point for instructional design in order to achieve 21st century skills. I agree with Wenglisky`s approach at this point. Educators need to shift towards constructivist environments. Today’s young learners need more critical thinking, higher order thinking. For years, the entire educational world stocked to Bloom’s first 2 or 3 steps of learning (knowledge-comprehension-application-analysis-synthesis-evaluation). In my opinion we need to look for the ways to improve students’ learning outcomes.
On the other hand, we need to alter the way we assess students. It should not just be limited with written exams, quizzes and the like. We need to focus on students’ learning outcomes, produces. Additionally, I am also aware of the fact that it is always more difficult to assess students according to their products. Teachers need more time, effort and thinking in order to assess students’ projects, products. Written exams, tests are always more attractive for teachers because all of the teachers have a mandated curriculum and state standards in hand.
Web supported learning environment:
First, I believe that Web will change the ways in which student learn, how they are willing to learn, how students are responsible for their own learning as it happens in Maine Laptop Initiative. Since I have been working on technology initiative of the state of Maine, I have realized that how an effective tool is the laptop.
The most important benefit of the web supported instruction design is more accurate and up-to-date information. When I think about my high school years, teacher and textbooks are the only source of information for me. My high school had good size library; however, school didn’t have a smiley librarian. To be honest, I had never visited the library in my high school years; therefore, my college student sister always searched for the information I needed in her university library. If we had Internet connected computers at school, I wouldn’t have to deal with any difficulty of reaching to information. Textbooks and teachers are the only source: therefore, in a non web supported environment, students don’t have a chance to communicate knowledge to many different perspectives. One of the biggest requirements of 21st century is being global citizenship. In my opinion, students will gain this characteristic only in a web supported environment.
Universities and K12 teachers always should go hand in hand. And one of the easiest ways to build learning communities is Web. For instance, Eric Langhorst, history teacher who created StudyCasts for his students to make them study on their test by listening Study Casts. As a result of StudyCasts, parents became more interested in their child’s learning, experts and authors involve to the classroom discussions (because Langhorst was using also blog to post the podcasts and to start a classroom discussion). Consequently, students were more engaged.
Well designed professional development:
While I was reading “Scaling up Success”, I was impressed how technology coordinators in other countries proposed the fact of time issue for teachers. Having a new technology, of course, will cause to spend more time. It is wise to cut at least 25percent of the curricula. By doing so, teacher spend more time thinking about how to integrate the new technology onto their content area. In Maine technology imitative, teachers have enough amount of train: however, they suffered from lack of time to design a web supported instruction.
Additionally, teachers should have professional development sessions which reflect the real life. Teachers should be involved in learning activities that are similar to their classroom activities.
References:
Wenglisky, Using technology wisely,
Chris DEDE and others, Scaling up success
Naime Kelekci, Best podcast practices
The Maine Learning Technology Initiative: Teacher, Student and School Perspectives Midyear evaluation report.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)