TQ9: In 3-to-5 paragraphs, discuss how these laws, and the policies that are developed to enforce the laws, should-or-should-not comply with the principle of least restraint. You should take a personal position here, as though you were a judge presiding over a challenge to the way a school or library has implemented a restrictive technology policy. An important consideration is that the laws are seldom clear, and that schools are given a wide range of possible ways to comply.
Internet is providing more accurate, up-date information for learners and educators at schools and libraries. However, current legal legislations (CIPA, COPPA and the likes) are restricting or denying access to information on the Internet. The most important issue with these legislations is safety which is OK. However, when I think about the first amendment of the US, I am having a hard time.
My interpretation about laws in the US is that every law regulated by US law authorities should be grounded in first amendment. First amendment says “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” In my opinion blocking or filtering Internet at school is the same idea with censorship. I believe that CIPA should be challenged according to first amendment.
While revisiting CIPA, regulators should think of what are the responsibilities of librarians, teachers and parents. Education is not just about schools. Home is another component of child’s education. If a school blocks computers at school, but home computers are not filtered by software or by adult. Kids still have an access to inappropriate content at home.
The other question crossing my mind is that why CIPA has been tied up with E-rate. It sounds like threatening people leaving them hungry. I believe that this side of the CIPA is the worst.
The other issue is that why we are filtering or blocking something is already in the air. I think we have to consider it. As a democratic country, US should develop another act for content creators. Content creators should learn to take into account of minor audiences.
CIPA and the likes are absolutely beneficial for K12. I think they are violating freedom of speech.
Sunday, October 26, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment